case analysis response assignment the ayala case
1. For this assignment carefully read “Case 2: The Ayala Case” from Burnor & Raley Ch.8, p. 171.
2. Write 500 words on the following question:
Was it morally permissible for the Ayala’s to conceive a child in the hope that it would be a compatible donor that could save their other child’s life?
You must use Kant’s moral theory somewhere in your answer.
Your response should include:
A. A brief summary of the main problem and relevant background facts and a clear statement of your position on the case. (see item number 1 in Guidelines for a Case Study Analysis in Burnor & Raley, pp. xxiii)
B. An argument in support of your position on the case, which includes a moral principle. (see items 3 & 4 in Guidelines for a Case Study Analysis in Burnor & Raley, pp. xxiii-xxiv)
C. Describe and respond to at least one possible objection to your position. (see item 5 in Guidelines for a Case Study Analysis in Burnor & Raley, pp. xxiv)
